There’s no point crying over spilt milk. England were simply horrendous throughout the World Cup, and that continued yesterday as they were humiliated by the first class opposition they’d played. The World Cup was a horror show for a number of reasons – and I’ll discuss those and the future of English football (yes what I think has wide reaching implications across English football) in my next post. First I’m going to dissect the players and the manager…just because it makes sense!
First the manager. He’s been stuck between a rock and a hard place. So the England players can’t take a boot camp for 5 weeks…pathetic, loads of people would’ve given anything to be on that plane to South Africa and they can’t concentrate on football for 5 weeks…HA!
But Capello did violate his “first principles” when he selected the World Cup squad by taking out-of-form players… Emile Heskey, Jamie Carragher and Matthew Upson have all had shocking seasons (well, to be fair Carraghers was by his own standards bad, he was ok). What about poor Darren Bent (2nd top English goalscorer in the Premier League), Gary Cahill (excellent for Bolton all season when fit) and of course Rio Ferdinand would’ve gone had he been fit. Carragher, Heskey and Upson should’ve been nowhere near the England squad.
Then his subs made no sense at all – Capello didn’t change the game once in any of England’s 4 games – he swapped like-for-like each and every time (I mean, Defoe for Heskey yesterday…gimme a break!), and that tactical stubborn-ness was a major issue in my view – England, and Capello, need to be more flexible in the future.
For the players it kind of goes without saying, but they lacked passion, they lacked self motivation, they lacked the ability to play as a team, and they, overall, were simply not good enough. How can they possibly play so well for their clubs and not for England? I think it’s time for a massive change (see next post!)
So I’m going to rate England’s manager and player out of 10 for their tournament performance…
Fabio Capello – 5 (tactical inflexibility, poor squad selection and substitutions, but limited by a squad who, frankly, seemed uninterested and were just not good enough).
Goalkeepers:
Rob Green – 5 (unfortunate mistake in the first game, not just his fault we didn’t beat the USA, but non-the-less made a big mistake)
David James – 6 (did his job well, unfortunately made some mistakes against Germany, but was the only one who really did his job).
Joe Hart – Should have been England’s number 1 this tournament, and definitely should be now.
Defenders:
Glen Johnson – 5 (good going forward usually, but not in this tournament, and was ruthlessly exposed against decent opposition)
John Terry – 4 (out of position, out of form, world class? don’t think so, couldn’t marshal a reasonably experienced back 4)
Matthew Upson – 4 (was poor in both his games, sure he scored against Germany, but he and the back 4 were directly responsible for the 4 German goals).
Ashley Cole – 6 (best English player at the finals, still defensively sound despite the failings of the other 3)
Jamie Carragher – 5 (poor, slow, past his best).
Michael Dawson – Never got on the pitch, shame, had an excellent season for Spurs. Must start the next game.
Ledley King – 7 (most talented English defender, played well in his only game against USA in the 1st half. Why did it have to be him that was injured?!)
Stephen Warnock – Was never gonna get a look in against Cole!
Midfielders:
Steven Gerrard – 6 (did ok, but he was played out of position on the left wing…oh dear oh dear, what a waste of genuine World Class talent)
Frank Lampard – 5 (was poor apart from 10 minutes against Germany when he showed what he could do)
James Milner – 6 (mixed, poor but unfit against the USA, fantastic against Solvenia, average against Germany. Did ok)
Gareth Barry – 4 (like all the other players, massively underperformed, especially against Germany)
Joe Cole – 4 (didn’t play much, wasn’t that great when he did)
Aaron Lennon – 4 (from what I saw, did next to nothing, final balls were awful)
Shaun Wright-Phillips – 4 (see Aaron Lennon)
Michael Carrick – did he get on the pitch? Don’t think so.
Attackers:
Wayne Rooney – 4 (what happened to the Rooney of Manchester United? Did nothing in 4 games)
Emile Heskey – 4 (why take a striker so woefully out of form, and who never looked like scoring, even when 1-on-1 against the US goalkeeper?)
Jermaine Defoe – 6 (did his job, got a goal, best of the strikers)
Peter Crouch – shoulda played, but didn’t. Shame, because he offers something different to the others, and goals.
In short, it was a woeful world cup. Yet you can bank on these players regularly scoring 7-10 for their clubs in the Premier League next season…apart from Heskey who can’t get in Villa’s team.